Soldier Boy — Context and Discussion

  4   0
Emshwiller, Ed, 1925-1990 [Illustrator], Shaara, Michael, 1929?-1988 Project Gutenberg 2016
Science fiction; War stories; Soldiers -- Fiction; Space colonies -- Fiction Readers of public-domain and historical texts
Project Gutenberg digital edition en

Edition facts

Words: 11,714
Reading time: 51 min
Text sections: 2
Michael Shaara's 1953 story follows Captain Dylan, a soldier from a forgotten war, as he defends a colony that despises him. The narrative contrasts civilian disdain with Dylan's internal awakening, using cold, snow, and a robot encounter to explore duty and identity.
Share

The story opens with a Scandinavian legend about a sleeping warrior, immediately framing the soldier as a mythic figure summoned in need. Shaara then undercuts this grandeur with a mundane, chilly morning: colonists grumble at an army ship's arrival, and no one goes out to greet it. The captain stands stiffly in the wind, tears gathering in his eyes from cold—a detail that humanizes him while the colonists suspect he is drunk. This tension between the legendary and the ordinary runs through the narrative.

Civilian Contempt and the Soldier's Isolation

Shaara establishes the colony's attitude through small, telling phrases. The colonists have been taught to hate war and, incidentally, to despise soldiers. When Captain Dylan arrives, they grumble in annoyance and stare with distaste. Bob Rossel, the spokesman, goes out only because the soldier looks small, cold, and pathetic. The dialogue reinforces this: Rossel grunts, “Nobody's in charge here,” and the colonists think, “God knows what's in the mind of a soldier.” The soldier's sloppy salute and low voice further mark him as an outsider. Shaara uses the setting—a freezing wind, snow-smelling breeze—to mirror the emotional chill between the colony and its defender.

Dylan's Internal Shift: From Resignation to Readiness

As Dylan waits for an attack, Shaara turns inward. Dylan realizes he is utterly without hope yet no longer afraid. A part of him has waited for this, and he marvels at feeling excited about a fight. The narrative voice becomes reflective: “he saw that this job was really his ... that he had always been, in truth, a soldier.” Shaara uses a remembered quote about exploding “in Technicolor” to capture Dylan's dark exhilaration. A small voice calls him “Barbarian,” but he cannot listen. This interior conflict—between civilized peace and primal warrior instinct—is the story's core, and Shaara renders it through Dylan's own surprised self-discovery.

The Robot Encounter: A Twist in the Snow

When a mailship arrives, hope flares, but Shaara undercuts it with a sudden threat. A white-coated, four-armed thing emerges from the woods, bobbing and shuffling. Dylan fires, hits it, and it falls—then rises and lurches away. The moment is tense and disorienting. Shaara builds dread through sensory details: Dylan hears the snow fall, and the camp falls silent. The crucial clue comes when Dylan picks up a severed paw: no blood, bone of steel, muscles of springs. It is a robot. This discovery shifts the enemy from a known animal to an unknown, manufactured foe, raising questions about who controls it and what the real war entails.

Voice and Diction: The Colonist's Vernacular

Shaara distinguishes the colonists through their casual, colloquial speech. Rush, the colonist who stays with Dylan, says things like “Some of those guys would walk barefoot through hell for a buck” and “It's getting a mite chilly.” He calls the robot “one o' them monkeys.” This folksy diction contrasts with Dylan's more formal, internal monologue. The colonists' language reflects their practical, dismissive attitude toward the soldier and the threat. Even when Rush is hopeful about the mailship, he speaks in short, blunt sentences: “She will take us all.” Shaara uses these speech patterns to ground the science-fiction premise in a recognizable, human-sounding community.

Shaara's story is notable for its economy: in a few thousand words, it establishes a colony's culture, a soldier's psychology, and a mysterious enemy. The excerpts leave the full nature of the aliens and Dylan's fate unclear, but the narrative's strength lies in its moment-by-moment tension and the quiet revelation of Dylan's identity. Readers attentive to the interplay between the colonists' disdain and Dylan's growing readiness will find a layered tale about what it means to be a soldier in a world that has forgotten why soldiers exist.

Related eBooks